Three Experts, No Conversation
An agent, a solicitor and a tax accountant, each right in their own lane, and the principal left to connect them.
The question this answers: why don’t my agent, solicitor and accountant coordinate when I sell an investment property with capital gains tax at stake?
When we decided to sell an investment property, the whole decision turned on one question: the capital gains tax. I had three capable professionals around me: the real estate agent, my solicitor and my tax accountant. Each gave me sound advice. None of them spoke to each other.
The agent was focused on the price and the market. The solicitor was focused on the contract and the settlement terms. The accountant was focused on the tax. Each was right within their own lane. But the decisions that mattered most for the tax outcome (when to sign, on what terms, held in which structure) were being shaped by the people furthest from the tax, while the person who understood it was often the last to see the plan. I was the only person who saw the whole thing, carrying questions back and forth between three offices, and the person least qualified to connect them.
Worth knowing: for property sold under a contract, the Australian Taxation Office treats the capital gains tax event as happening when the contract is signed, not at settlement. Timing questions are settled at signing, which is before many families bring their accountant into the room.
A year later, the second problem surfaced. When I needed to revisit why we had made certain choices, nobody could say exactly. The reasoning was scattered across email threads with three different firms. The decision had been made, but the record of the decision had not.
This is not a criticism of advisers. It is a structural gap. Professionals are engaged for their part of the problem, and nobody is engaged for the joins between the parts. In most families, that job falls silently to the principal.
Now every significant decision we make is recorded in one place: what each adviser said, what we chose, and why. Each adviser can see what is relevant to them. I stopped being the switchboard.
Three questions for this month
- When did your solicitor and accountant last speak to each other about your affairs?
- For your last major decision, could you find the reasoning in under five minutes?
- Who, other than you, is responsible for making your advisers’ advice fit together?
This essay is part of an ongoing series; the full library is on the writing page.
The extension of the series, usually weekly: questions asked and answered, the governance pulse, and what the family is watching next. Everything published is practised first.